Thursday, October 7, 2010

Maybelline Stylish Smokes: Review & Swatches

Hey everyone!
How has the week been treating you? Mine started fine, and then I got a horribly sore throat! It started small on Tuesday, and then in the night & early Wednesday things got worse. I could tell I had a fever in the night, and my throat hurt so bad- I had to really strain to talk and swallow. Needless to say, I couldn't go to work & anchor the news! Wednesday afternoon I saw the doctor and he prescribed me antibiotics for strep throat. He said I'd be contagious for about 24 hours and confirmed for me that my throat was "super swollen". It was definitely worse than any sore throat I've ever had, and it has restricted my voice big time. So I wasn't able to to go work today either. (Our first day in HD, I'm bummed). My throat still hurts a lot, but I don't feel the headachey, feverish, borderline ear-ache symptoms I had yesterday. I've purchased some soft, cool foods like yogurt, applesauce, and also some popsicles- which are supposed to soothe the swelling. My advice- see a doctor if you are experiencing an unrelenting sore throat that's affecting your ability so speak and swallow. Nip it in the bud before it turns into something worse! Thanks to all who've tweeted me and facebooked me with kind messages!! :)


Now to the content you're really after-- my review of the Stylish Smokes quads! I opted to do this in blog form due to my vocal difficulties. Thanks to Ashley for requesting this! She's a regular on the Beauty Broadcast facebook page & has also started her own YouTube channel.

This collection is not brand new to Maybelline. It's been out for awhile, but not until recently have I purchased the entire set. They cost somewhere between 5 & 6 bucks, depending on location. As you can see, you get a generous amount of each shade, and 2 sponge tip applicators with each palette. All palettes label the shades as lid, crease, brow bone, and outer corner. It's a good default way to apply them, but use your own preferences and creativity to create different looks! Overall, I REALLY like these palettes because each of them comes with a really dark shade! So many drugstore palettes give you 3 or 4 colors that are all light to medium shades with nothing to really give you some contrast! Read on to see how I feel about each individual palette!

left to right: Natural Smokes, Charcoal Smokes, Emerald Smokes, Amethyst Smokes



NATURAL SMOKES


The Natural Smokes quad is my favorite! While all of the other palettes contain shimmer in all of their colors, this palette has 2 matte shades (the bottom 2). ALL of these colors are pigmented, and those top 2 colors are truly gorgeous! (shimmery taupe & shimmery brownish-copper). You can get a really nice smokey eye with this kit- and that matte brown is super blendable and BUILDABLE. Terrific palette for fall! Gives you lots of options- you can leave out the dark brown for a more natural look- or use the brown as a liner!


CHARCOAL SMOKES


This was the first palette I purchased from the Stylish Smokes collection. Because I wasn't absolutely crazy about it, I didn't go ahead & purchase the others for awhile (had to be convinced by fellow youtubers). I think those top 2 shimmery shades are fabulous, the highlight shade was nice, but not really unique, and the black shade was a disappointment. I had to dip back into the palette 3 to 4 times to get the swatch you see there of the black. You CAN build it up on your eye to get some contrast, but I will usually turn to another black in my collection from NYX, MAC, or Cover Girl that is easier to work with-- with less effort. Out of the four, this palette probably comes in 4th place-- but it's still not bad and I wear it quite often to work (minus the black shade)


EMERALD SMOKES


YAY for Emerald Smokes. This is a close, close second for me behind Natural Smokes. The shades in this palette are SO unique- I don't run across them very often in the drugstore. I love the way this looks on my eyes! You really can achieve anywhere from a subtle olive look to a deep sultry green look! I like wearing the brighter green labeled "crease" all over my lid- because it really pops! The brow bone shade has a pretty yellow undertone- SO gorgeous! And that darkest green with sparkle is truly pigmented and DARK! I loved using this palette in my Michigan State gameday look & got lots of good feedback. All of the shades are shimmery, but they're all so beautiful, I don't mind :)


AMETHYST SMOKES


Amethyst smokes- the last palette I picked up in this collection. That gorgeous purple with the blue undertone kept drawing me in, but I could tell that the black was the exact same black that was in Charcoal smokes & I knew I hated that color! Seriously, Maybelline! Why would you re-use the single worst color in the whole collection?! I'm not trying to be mean, but come on! That purple shade on the upper left is beautiful, and the other purple is lovely as well. The light shade is nothing all that special. The purples are the saving grace of this palette and have allowed me to create some lovely looks. Just be prepared to sub in a better plum or black for the black that comes with the set. This palette is 3rd place for me.


That's all everyone! Thanks for taking the time to read this long blog! Hopefully it gives you some solid info on these palettes & lets you know what ones you might be interested in buying! Have a good day & good luck to all the others out there who are dealing with sickness as the weather changes! Feel better soon! :)
Em

24 comments:

  1. I loooove all of these colors! I'm definitely going to go check them out! They seem very pigmented!

    XOXO, Cupcake

    http://thecupcakecartel.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice swatches! I love that green in Emerald Smokes. You would think they would have had a second green in it though.

    ReplyDelete
  3. These are awesome! I have one in designer chocolates. I LOVE LOVE LOVE LOVE it! I have never had a a quad that I have used so much. I can create so many different looks with this. It does need a good base though in my opinion. I'll definately be picking some more up :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love these quads. They are all sooo pretty! Ulta had a 40% off before this and i regret not getting any.

    xx

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thanks for the review. I've been really wanting the natural smokes and just haven't boughten it yet. I need to get it! Glad you're feeling better.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I LOVE these quads. I'm with you though, the natural smokes is my favorite and I feel like it might be the most versatile of the four. The emerald smokes is also my second favorite, but I subbed out the black for a dark brown and almost had a kind of "camo" eye look, but still very pretty. Thank you so much for your posts and videos, I always look forward to them.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I have most of these quads and they are quickly becoming favorites!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow i love all of these. I like the idea of the labelling on them,they would be great for my teenage daughter.It's like painting by numbers lol. Thanks for posting. x

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you so much for the swatches!! :) The disappointing thing is that each quad contains a quite glittery and not pigmented color :/

    ReplyDelete
  10. These look gorgeous and for such a great price I reckon it'd be worth buying them all! The purple shades are particularly lovely and I bet you could create LOADS of different looks with them!

    Hope you manage to get plenty of rest and feel better soon! P.S it's so unfair that you still look so good when you're sick. If I'm ill I always look a complete mess! :)

    http://mytopbeautybuys.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  11. Love this blog, I'm definitely going to go out and snag some of these. Do you happen to know if they have that purple with the blue undertones in the amethyst one in a single shadow? I'd definitely buy that. Thanks for this and get well soon!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great review! I have the Amethyst Smokes quad and am wanting to get the Emerald Smokes one. Love your swatches too. I do hope you're feeling a little better!

    Best wishes and Halls cough drops, Kris

    http://neutrakris.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  13. I hope you feel better soon.
    I only wish Maybelline was cruelty free! I'd be buying so much of their stuff if they were!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks for the review, I love the studio quads they have at the moment the sparkle is amazing. Haven't seen these ones in the UK though. x

    ReplyDelete
  15. I recently bought both the Natural Smokes & Charcoal Smokes, and your review on these are dead-on. I love the Natural Smokes one - especially the shimmery shades! I was hesitant about the Charcoal Smokes and only picked it up b/c I needed some greys and Maybelline was 40% off at Ulta. I think this one is just ok- really don't like the black in this one!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I love the emerald shades. ♥

    www.madeupbyhannah.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. beautiful shadows!! i need to get my hands on these soon

    ps please check out my beauty blog iam new iam open to advice and any suggestions xxoxoxo
    http://ebeautyny.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  18. i love the color selections of these :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. I have Natural and Charcoal smokes and I really like them both, although Natural is my favourite too. I haven't been really sure about purchasing the rest, but after reading this review, I might get the Emerald palette as well.

    ReplyDelete
  20. thanks for the post!
    they all look so pretty, especially the purple colors :D

    ReplyDelete
  21. These are awesome products especially for beginners ;]

    ReplyDelete
  22. Emily! I love your youtube channel and just discovered your Beauty Broadcase even though I know it's been around for a while. I bought one of these quades (and love it) but I couldn't bring myself to buy the others because I own a lot of MAC eyeshadows that look similar. Now I know you've started a dupes list (which is incredible by the way) but I didn't see dupes for these products. This is kind of a reverse dupe request but can you post some MAC look-a-like shadows for these quads?

    ReplyDelete
  23. amazing nice color . and also like review ....

    ReplyDelete