Friday, November 6, 2015

Another Look: Maybelline Lip Gloss Palette

Hi Everyone!
Second blog of the week, yay! Actually, what prompted this blog were all the comments and questions about a palette that I featured in an "Under $25" palette/gift set video a couple of weeks ago. More recently, fellow YouTuber Tati a.k.a. GlamLifeGuru did a video on this palette. She's an awesome reviewer, not to mention absolutely gorgeous! While she enjoyed this palette, I did not, and I noticed many of you asking me for clarification, new swatches, a second try, etc. So I thought I'd do that for you in this blog post... as I merely swatched this palette in my video and didn't show each color on my lips. Please keep in mind- different people are going to have different opinions on products. I've been on YouTube for 8 years and there have been many occasions (and probably even more than I'm aware of) where my opinions were different from people who I admire and respect! No big earth-shattering revelation there. We are going to talk about products based on the way we're going to use them! The key is really staying consistent with your criteria as you review products of a similar type. That being said, here's another look at the palette. 
This lip gloss palette sells for $11.99 at Ulta. In my video I was talking about the fact that many of these colors came off similar to one another, and with the way I'm willing to apply them... they do. I didn't really scoop the product out for my swatches or application, and I never do that with lip palettes. I'm generally not a fan of building up a gloss-type product on my lips to achieve more color. The thick feel isn't something I enjoy... and frankly, with so many products in my collection that apply with ease and look great with a swipe or two- I don't have a ton of patience for something that is going to take added work in application. Just my personal take. 
In these swatches, I layered two swipes per color... basically the equivalent of doing two layers over my lips. Could you go much thicker and achieve more color? Absolutely. However for my preferences in texture, I do not like to wear these thick on my lips. As I've stated often in my reviews, a thick amount of a shiny finish product- paired with a bright color- can be a bit more high maintenance to keep track of... for example, I'm more likely to wear a matte red out and about as opposed to a shiny red gloss. It's less upkeep & less worry about something drifting outside the lips, onto teeth, etc. This is purely personal preference. And I appreciate many of you suggesting that I wear these thick to achieve more color- because, naturally, that would be the thing to do if you want more color! However if I don't like the feel of the product piled on my lips, I'm not going to wear it that way. 
The top row is the first four shades in the palette, and the bottom row is the last four shades. I built up two layers of the product on my lips- again, that's the way I'm willing to wear it. As you can see, the deeper shades have more intensity, and overall, the top row (and the first on the bottom row) look like rather similar shades of pink, and the final three are similar reds. I don't think these products look bad on my lips! But as I mentioned in my video, these colors don't come off drastically different one to the next, and for around $11 I'd like to see more variation in shades and more pigmentation. Maybe some deeper neutrals? Plums? Also, there is no mirror in this palette and I think that's pretty important for touch-ups. Bottom line: I adore lip products and I have loads that I love. Just keeping it real with you though-- I'm probably not going to reach for this palette very often. But as always, I'm just here to share my 2 cents and everyone is entitled to make their own decisions! Everyone doesn't have to think the same, and I think we should ENCOURAGE unique perspectives :) 

83 comments:

  1. You took my exact thoughts Emily. I was thinking during her review and going through the comments, you could easily build the colour up but I don't want a thick layer of lipstick or gloss on my lips. If you want a pigmented colour, you shouldn't have to dig a brush or finger to get the colour.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I never doubt your reviews. These colors DO look the same when you use a realistic amount of product. Definitely not a palette I would be interested in. To be honest, I don't see Tati using this now that she's reviewed it. It's just not a practical application method for gloss.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great swatches, they look so pretty on you! I agree, probably not a palette that I'd reach for often though. Thanks for this post!

    http://www.alysamadisun.com/

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have not watched Tati's review yet, but I know she does build up the colors for swatches, which is fine with most products but I think you were spot on with this one. I can't imagine wanting to do more than two layers of lip gloss, and I probably wouldn't even do that. Especially if I have a lipstick underneath. The first four pictures look exactly the same, but as if you did it in a tad different lighting. Not worth it just for that alone. Plus, in my opinion....lip gloss is supposed to be quickly applied. I wouldn't buy this palette because of that alone. If it was a pigmented lipstick palette, then yes. But not lip gloss! Thanks for your great review!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lip swatches are so tricky I've learned because people's natural lip pigment is SO different, just like skin tone colours show up completely different!!

    Kat | www.kathorrocks.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. This palette looks gorgeous! And good job Maybelline for creating something like this! Just for me personally, I don't think it is something I am going to buy.

    xx, A Little Dose of Makeup

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love you and I love Tati and always watch both of your videos. It's always good to hear reviews from different people with different opinions and styles and then make up your own mind about what might work for you. BTW, I agree with you on this one :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's so lovely to see you blogging actively now! Yeay!
    Malaysian suscriber here!
    I think Maybelline would have done better with a lipstick palette instead of a lip gloss one.
    -Hari

    ReplyDelete
  9. I like these colors!
    xo
    Stacy

    http://tastyrumors.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree with your bottom line and you're better than me because I would not have reviewed it a second time. Keep being and doing you Emily (it's what makes you trustworthy), and I'll keep being a supporter.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The colors are super gorgeous though when I watched Tati's video, but personally I also don't like building up gloss type products that are pigmented (I'm messy). :) Thanks for the review!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Condannato al carcere a Milano ad inizio anni 2000. "Il funzionario di Citibank in grossi guai" come da finale del seguente articolo era lui.
    http://archiviostorico.corriere.it/2001/febbraio/02/Arrestato_imprenditore_delle_truffe_fiscali_co_7_0102023408.shtml
    Cacciato a sberle, poi, da Citibank, e fatto condannare al carcere dalla stessa Citibank.
    ---
    In possesso della tessera di ... tenetevi forte, pls, and stra pls "ORGOGLIO PEDOFILO".
    https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAMBLA
    STO SCHIFOSO DEPRAVATO ... LO DEVO DIRE... IN QUANTO VERO... SODOMIZZA BAMBINI, SODOMIZZA ZINGARELLI DI 10-12 ANNI, CHE E' STO ACCLARATISSIMO PEDERASTA DI PAOLO BARRAI, RAGLIA SPESSISSIMO IN PRIVATO: "NEL LATIN AMERICA CHE TANTO AMO, E' FACILE FARE SESSO CON RAGAZZINI DI 10-14 ANNI... TANTE BAMBINE DI 12-14 ANNI RIMANGONO IN CINTA.. QUINDI, IO SCOPO I BAMBINI, BEVO IL LORO PRIMO SPERMA... SON PEDOFILO E ME NE VANTO". HO SENTITO QUESTI SUOI DISCORSI DA VOMITO ANCHE IO, QUANDO VENNE A TROVARCI A MODENA.
    (http://ilpunto-borsainvestimenti.blogspot.be/2013/03/lunedi-11-marzo-cena-modena-per-parlare.html)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Fece comprare a Mafia, Camorra e Ndrangheta ( suoi veri e soli clienti.. che se ne fregano delle performances, volendo solo lavara capitali assassini) case in Brasile, nel Marzo 2011, e da allora il Real Brasiliano ha perso "solo" il 60% per cento.
    http://www.xe.com/currencycharts/?from=BRL&to=EUR
    http://www.forexinfo.it/Real-brasiliano-rischia-il-tracollo-tra-crisi-economica-e-politica
    Fece comprare l'oro a 1800 dollari, nell'Estate 2011, ed a seguire, lo stesso, e' "solo" precipitato fino a 1160 dollari.
    Fece comprare il petrolio a 105 dollari e passa, nella primavera 2014, e lo stesso, e' caduto in un baratro: giu fino a 43 dollari attuali!
    Raglio' di "dedollarizzazione", a fine 2011, mentre l'euro valeva 1,40 contro un dollaro, e lo stesso dollaro ha poi guadagnato un 30% e passa contro l'euro.
    Ma vi rendete conto di quanto vi sputtanerete in tutto il mondo e per sempre, ad accostarvi a... parole sue.. sto "bevitore di primo sperma di bambini dodicenni", quale il gia' tante volte in galera, verminoso pedofilomosessuale Paolo Barrai di criminalissima Wmo sa Panama e criminalissima Bsi Italia srl di via Socrate 26 a Milano? Scritto per mero vostro bene. Questo e' solo un antipastino su chi e' davvero sto mega truffatore e mega avanzo di galera di Paolo Barrai. Fra poco mi stra scatenero' giorno e notte. A fra non molto. giannipanni@gmx.com.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Herein lies the exact reason you are #1 on my Youtube channel list to watch! More times than not, the results/reviews you give for products are spot on for me. I'm not one who really likes a lip gloss. I especially don't like a thick one on my lips either. Everything you told us in your video is plain to see in this blog post. I appreciate you going the extra mile with your reviews.

    ReplyDelete
  15. that looks really nice, but I don't think that this is a product I'll be buying! I think the colors are just too similar for me to get much use out of them
    -Sisi
    Modern Beauty Girl

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great concept but the colors do look super similar! Thank you for an honest review Emily!

    HashtagFabLife

    ReplyDelete
  17. I'm so happy you reviewed this product bc I was going to purchase it. Now that I see the colors, I'm glad I haven't purchased it. Im so sad the colors arent more vivid. Great review though! :)

    macysbeautyblog.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  18. Thank you for going the extra mile to review this palette. I didn't request it but I think it is so great to see a YouTuber be so thoughtful and go the extra mile to help her subscribers. I always appreciate and look forward to your reviews :) Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  19. $12 for 8 glosses that look similar to each other definitely does not seem worth it. Thanks for the honest review, as always!

    ReplyDelete
  20. I'm not even a lipgloss fan really but these look so nice! thanks for the great post - i love your reviews and i love the look of all the lighter shades heheh xx

    http://hollouwebb.blogspot.co.uk/

    ReplyDelete
  21. Tips that every one want to make this lip gloss, this great tips for women beauty.
    women earrings

    ReplyDelete
  22. I totally agree! I think if I ha e to be uncomfortable for it to look good, it's not worth it! Especially not when I have a red lipstick that feels nice and applies full color in 1-2 swipes... I'm not a huge fan of lip gloss either.. Just personal preference...

    ReplyDelete
  23. I totally agree! I think if I ha e to be uncomfortable for it to look good, it's not worth it! Especially not when I have a red lipstick that feels nice and applies full color in 1-2 swipes... I'm not a huge fan of lip gloss either.. Just personal preference...

    ReplyDelete
  24. Directory listing online had been a very popular search tool.
    Book Cabs in Mumbai Online

    ReplyDelete
  25. Thank you for the information you provide, i like camera b612 | download camera b612 | camera b612 | download b612 | download camera b612 | B612 | download camera b612 | b612 | download camera b612 | papa games | Papas Games | papa's games | Dream League Soccer | Score Hero | Dream League Soccer | Score Hero game | Score Hero. How about you? B612 is perfect for taking selfies anytime, anywhere. B612 is a photography app specially designed for selfies that lets you apply dozens of filters to your images before sharing them through your favorite social networks.
    Free Games Online | free games | free online games | Free Games Online | free games

    ReplyDelete
  26. You can check all details about education,results,and regular update about all information click here
    Bihar Board 10th Result 2016
    MP Board 10th Result 2016
    Madhyamik Result 2015

    ReplyDelete
  27. Great post indeed!
    ACtually I visit your blog first time through someone blog. So I bookmakred this page for further usage.
    Thanks for sharing such great content with us.

    Happy Mothers Day Wishes 2016 | Happy Mothers Day Messages 2016 | Happy Mothers Day Quotes 2016 | Happy Mothers Day Sms 2016 | Happy Mothers Day Images 2016

    Happy Mothers Day Wishes 2016
    Happy Mothers Day Messages 2016
    Happy Mothers Day Quotes 2016
    Happy Mothers Day Sms 2016
    Happy Mothers Day Images 2016

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thanks for sharing!! Read more valuable article about Why Dental Implants are the Best Choice for Tooth Replacement on
    Dental Implants webpage

    ReplyDelete
  29. Amazing Information Thanks, You can share Happy National Sister Day 2016 Images , Photos, and poems with your family & with your sister brother. Don't forget to share it.
    This page is about sister day 2016.
    National sister day
    This page is about Sister day gifts
    National sister day gifts
    This is our main homepage, where you can get all information about sister day 2016
    National siblings day

    ReplyDelete
  30. nice tips, thank you E, hope you can share more amazing tips
    gmail correo electronico

    ReplyDelete
  31. I have read this above post its very greatful for me thanks sharing this post ,great post.
    know your pan card detail using pan number

    ReplyDelete
  32. This can Patch all your applications to customize and restrict permissions and activities
    lucky patcher apk download

    ReplyDelete

  33. this above post its very greatful for me thanks sharing this post ,getting more know your pan status is easy to me

    ReplyDelete
  34. Now if this was a LIPSTICK pallete, I’d be throwing my money at it, but I’m underwhelmed with this. R Programming Training | DataStage Training | SQL Training | SAS Training | Android Training | SharePoint Training

    ReplyDelete
  35. Thanks for the beauty tips! I've got new articles at
    Medium

    ReplyDelete
  36. I blog quite often and I seriously appreciate your content. This great article has really peaked my interest. I'm going to bookmark your website and keep checking for new details about once per week. I opted in for your RSS feed as well...

    الامل كلين
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركة مكافحة حشرات
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركات كشف تسربات المياه
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركات عزل الاسطح
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركة كشف تسربات بجدة
    http://www.alamalclean.com/

    ReplyDelete

  37. الامل كلين
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركة مكافحة حشرات
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركات كشف تسربات المياه
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركات عزل الاسطح
    http://www.alamalclean.com/
    شركة كشف تسربات بجدة
    http://www.alamalclean.com/

    ReplyDelete